candybutthole:
4th-doctor-whooves:
pallidbatman:
4th-doctor-whooves:
pallidbatman:
Fandom secret: When it comes to My Little Pony my reaction is anywhere from “meh” to “why are you telling me about this?”
I don’t hate it.
But I don’t really like it either.
The songs are fucking catchy as hell I’ll give it that.
I’m going to do the main ponies (plus Spike) as little cutouts for Ramencon because I have nothing fandom related to sell and none of my original stuff sold last year :/
Fluttershy and Rarity are all done.
Lol, I can tell you are indifferent, hence the manly faces and caricature-like appearances of their physical features. XD Sorry but these look terribly laughable XD Well drawn and they obviously took some talent but man, they look awful XD Why do so many artists insist on making human versions of characters look like transgendered men?
I think you mean trangendered women?
And there’s nothing wrong with trans women. They’re women. Simple as that. I really could care less about whether or not you think the designs are awful but spare me the remark about trans people and at least take the time to get it right if you’re going to be offensive.
So I would like to congratulate you for not only saying that women can’t have masculine features but also saying that transgender women are actually men.
Good job.
Lol, I love how you think I said it as a slight to transgendered people as opposed to how you’re using the look of transgendered people as an aesthetic in art for humanizing characters and how i think it look terrible…and it does. Lol, what would you do if I were transgendered? Hmmmm? Why don’t YOU think before you speak?
Lol, yes, no women can have masculine features! That is exactly what I meant. XD Good job reading my mind XD If you don’t like the critique then don’t post publicly. Also the twit that commented that I’m a butthurt Brony? XD Get over yourself. I would say the same thing about anyone that draws art where the characters are SO off model to be laughable.
you are fucking disgusting
it isn’t a critique if you don’t find them attractive, suprisingly enough not every woman has to be drawn to be conventionally attractive for the male gaze!!!! think of that!!!!!
and they aren’t off model at all, they are humanized versions. how can they be off model? oh, you mean they aren’t thin, conventionally attractive, and white with feminine features? is that an ‘off’ model human to you?
and fyi peppering your sentences with XD doesn’t make them less awful; arguably moreso, even
Lol, I am going to respond to this last one here because again, it’s hilarious.
“it isn’t a critique if you don’t find them attractive, suprisingly enough not every woman has to be drawn to be conventionally attractive for the male gaze!!!! think of that!!!!!”
Lol, I never said they HAD to be nor did I say I wanted them to be. You’re really reaching trying to shove meaning into what i said that isn’t there. Nothing about this has anything to do with me finding them attractive based on conventions of what the mainstream finds beautiful. Think of THAT.
“and they aren’t off model at all, they are humanized versions. how can they be off model? oh, you mean they aren’t thin, conventionally attractive, and white with feminine features? is that an ‘off’ model human to you?”
Yes! That’s exactly what I meant! I’m so glad you really KNOW the REAL me!
Now on to my ACTUAL reply. Fluttershy looks stereotypically rail thin and frail. As if her design were based on how gentle she is without regard to her actual strength and yeah I even mean physically. In terms of the show she’s supposed to be gorgeous naturally enough to be runway model material and while it IS true that IRL many runway models are indeed stick figures I find the idea to be an odd thing to do to Shy there as i always pictured her to be a bit more motherly and in that regard with more weight on her body or a nurturers sort of a frame and that that natural body type would make her perfect to be a more filled out model. I never pictured the reason why Fluttershy was a runway model to be because she was so THIN like a supermodel…actually thinner as this artist drew her with a Cruella DeVille frame. Instead the artist seemed to equate her love of animals and being gentle to being a waif and I think it looks off. Rarity also feels wrong. She strikes me, in context to the show with someone who places value on their appearance and fitness, you know, so she she can wear the latest creations and look good in it. She is dainty in her etiquette and how she presents herself and while she has been known to binge eat from time to time when she’s upset and while I pictured her to be more heavy set than the others I still pictured her to be more fit. She’s presented as a strongly determined hard worker…so yeah I find the idea that she looks like an overweight, over-privilaged diva with the wrong hair style model to be wrong. In many ways it seems that the artists unfamiliarity with the show led him to pick one aspect of the character as a defining trait and RUN with it, doing their own thing instead of looking at the multiple aspect of them and thinking of the practical natures of the design. If it wasn’t for them being labeled as the characters or having the right hair colors they wouldn’t have come CLOSE to being confused with the characters on the show in human form. If any pony in human form is more plump, it’s the always eating sweets pastry chef Pinkie Pie. If any character would have a more masculine frame and face its AJ, hell she puts more physical labor into her life that it makes sense, though Rainbow would also be a good candidate for looking boyish but I find that to be based more on how she acts sometimes rather than her appearance because we all know she and AJ can look downright feminine in the right circumstances…well, again based in context to the show and the situation with the Gala dresses and the same goes with Rainbow. If I thought any character was a thin character it was Twilight as she is kinda a book nerd and while I know that is a sort of stereotype in itself most bookish girls I know fit it. Most of this however is based on their environment rather than standards of beauty because you are correct in one thing, these are humanization’s of animal characters. Translating them is difficult because they all use the same base character model but incorporating their jobs, their personalities, habits and lifestyles and how other characters view their appearance in the show give you a good idea as to what they should look like and I feel that these do not do that any justice.I also realize that MOST people would agree that there are people that would feel otherwise but I’m presenting MY opinion and in MY opinion these look bad.
BTW, I just LOVE how you added “you mean they aren’t thin, conventionally attractive, and white” White? Were you expecting me to say that I think Rarity’s skin color is a factor in this? XD If so you’re SADLY mistaken. I’m sure you’d LOVE to throw “racist” as well on top of “transphobic” and “misogynistic” too but really, you’re reaching here trying to make me out into some sort of *gasp* evil villainous person. Stop the self induced drama. XD
And yeah i add the XD because I find everyone’s reaction to be laughable. so XD…XDXDXDXDXDXDXDXDXDXDMUTHAFUKKA!